From Diagnosing Diseases To Mental Health Issues: Why Relying On ChatGPT For Healthcare Is Risky

If you’ve ever typed your symptoms into ChatGPT, you are one of the millions of people who have turned to the AI chatbot for quick answers about their health—whether it’s a strange rash, recurring headaches, or even feelings of anxiety. The responses often sound confident, sometimes even reassuring but here’s the interesting thing, confidence doesn’t equal accuracy.Stop for a second and ask yourself- would you trust an internet search result to make a medical decision for you? Then why do so many of us feel comfortable letting a chatbot take on that role? While ChatGPT is brilliant at conversation, it isn’t a doctor, a licensed therapist, or even a safe substitute for any professional care.Artificial intelligence has surged into daily life in ways few could have imagined even three years ago. Among these tools, ChatGPT—the large language model developed by OpenAI—has become one of the most widely adopted. Launched in late 2022, it crossed 100 million users in just two months, a record for consumer technology. Its ability to mimic natural conversation, draft essays, generate code, and even pass law exams has fueled endless fascination. Bill Gates himself has declared it as transformative as the personal computer or the internet.But the rush to embrace AI raises pressing questions when it comes to healthcare. What happens when people begin turning to ChatGPT for medical guidance or emotional support? A growing body of research suggests that while the chatbot has value in certain contexts, relying on it for diagnosing diseases or mental health treatment carries serious risks.Why Is The Idea Of A Digital Doctor So Alluring?ChatGPT’s popularity rests on its uncanny ability to sound human. Type in a question about a rash, a persistent cough, or a wave of anxiety, and within seconds it generates paragraphs of plausible-sounding advice. For someone unable to see a doctor immediately—or someone simply curious—it can feel like having a physician or therapist on demand.That accessibility is no small thing. Nearly half of people who could benefit from therapy, for example, never receive it. Primary care wait times in many countries, including the United States, can stretch for weeks. Against that backdrop, a free, always-available AI tool looks like a lifeline.Yet what makes ChatGPT appealing—its speed and confidence—is also what makes it dangerous. The model doesn’t understand health, disease, or psychology. It predicts words based on patterns in its training data. Sometimes those predictions are accurate. Other times, they’re dangerously wrong.Does ChatGPT Turns Curiosity Into Misdiagnosis Of Physical Health Issues?It’s common for users to feed symptoms into ChatGPT, hoping for quick clarity. But the answers it returns can veer from banal to catastrophic. A simple headache may come back with possibilities ranging from dehydration to brain tumor. One user who typed in details about a chest lump was told it could be cancer. In reality, it was a lipoma—a benign fatty growth that occurs in about one in every thousand people.This kind of “worst-case scenario medicine” has consequences. It can fuel unnecessary anxiety, encourage inappropriate self-treatment, or delay people from seeking professional evaluation. Unlike a licensed physician, ChatGPT cannot order diagnostic tests, perform a physical exam, or rule out conditions with clinical judgment. Nor does it carry malpractice insurance for when it gets things wrong.That’s not to say ChatGPT has no role at all in supporting patients. It can translate dense medical jargon into plain English, help organize a symptom timeline before a doctor visit, or suggest questions to ask during an appointment. Used this way, it may even make healthcare interactions more productive. But it cannot replace medical expertise.For Mental HealthThe risks grow sharper in the realm of mental health. Therapy is not just about words—it’s about connection, trust, and the ability to navigate nuance in real time. A human therapist listens not only to what is said but also to tone, pauses, and body language. They are bound by professional codes and legal responsibilities designed to protect patients from harm.ChatGPT offers none of that. It can suggest breathing exercises, grounding techniques, or motivational reframing. But it lacks lived experience and genuine empathy. It cannot detect suicidal ideation buried between the lines of a text prompt. Worse, because its training data reflect biases in society, its advice may unintentionally reinforce stigma or harmful stereotypes.A recent Stanford study underscored these dangers. Researchers found that AI therapy chatbots were not only less effective than human therapists but could also introduce dangerous biases. “LLM-based systems are being used as companions, confidants, and therapists, and some people see real benefits,” said Nick Haber, assistant professor at the Stanford Graduate School of Education and senior author of the study. “But we find significant risks, and it’s important to lay out the safety-critical aspects of therapy.”For anyone in true crisis, relying on a chatbot could be catastrophic. In the U.S., dialing 988 connects callers with trained counselors on the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. No AI can—or should—fill that role.Could AI Help in Healthcare?To be clear, the lesson is not that AI has no place in medicine. In fact, carefully designed AI applications already help radiologists detect tumors, assist pathologists in analyzing slides, and streamline hospital logistics. Within mental health, AI tools could be useful for lower-stakes applications: supporting journaling, coaching, or serving as training partners for clinicians.ChatGPT itself may be most valuable not as a doctor or therapist but as an adjunct tool. It could handle administrative tasks like insurance documentation, or simulate standardized patients for medical students in training. These applications carry lower risks and could free up professionals to spend more time in direct care.Why Using ChatGPT for Healthcare Is Both A Temptation and A Trap?Why, then, are so many tempted to turn to ChatGPT for healthcare? Part of the answer lies in access. Millions lack affordable healthcare or mental health services, and AI seems to fill the gap. Another part lies in psychology: people trust confident voices, and ChatGPT is nothing if not confident.But confidence is not competence. Without guardrails, users risk mistaking eloquent text for expert judgment. In health, that distinction matters profoundly.AI chatbots represent one of the most exciting technological shifts in recent history. They are powerful, versatile, and often astonishing. But they are not a substitute for trained medical professionals. Using ChatGPT to draft a grocery list or outline an essay? Safe. Using it to decide whether a lump is cancerous or to guide you through a depressive episode? Risky at best, dangerous at worst.The path forward requires balance. We should embrace the efficiencies AI can bring while holding firm to the principle that human health—whether physical or mental—requires human judgment. As the Stanford study reminds us, innovation should not come at the cost of safety.If you or someone you know is struggling with mental health challenges, seek support from a licensed professional. In the United States, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available 24/7 by dialing 988. No chatbot can take the place of that call.Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and should not replace professional medical advice. Always consult a licensed healthcare provider for diagnosis, treatment, or mental health support.

From Diagnosing Diseases To Mental Health Issues: Why Relying On ChatGPT For Healthcare Is Risky

Quick Stories

Could You Reverse Hair Loss And Regrow Bald Spots? New Chemical Agent Could Increase Hair Density by 20%

Dermatologist Reveals Why Using The Same Skincare Day And Night Could Be Ruining Your Skin

Half of People With Diabetes Go Undiagnosed, Lancet Study Warns

Health Conditions A-Z

As RFK Jr's Planned Report Fuels Autism-Tylenol Debate: What 25 Years of CDC Data Really Show?

Could You Reverse Hair Loss And Regrow Bald Spots? New Chemical Agent Could Increase Hair Density by 20%

Dermatologist Reveals Why Using The Same Skincare Day And Night Could Be Ruining Your Skin