Why Women Are Walking Into An Obesity Crisis With Weak Knees?

Updated Mar 5, 2025 | 07:00 PM IST

SummaryObesity increases knee osteoarthritis risk, with 33% of joint replacement surgeries involving obese patients. Women's wider pelvis and lower muscle mass make them more prone to knee injuries and osteoarthritis.
Are Women Walking Into An Obesity Crisis With Weak Knees?

Image Credit: Health and me

Obesity is widely known as a cause of long-term health disorders like diabetes and heart disease, but its unnoticed effect on joint health—specifically the knees—is less recognized. Research indicates that women specifically are experiencing a growing load of knee-related complications as a result of being overweight. This prompts a important question: Are female joints at a disadvantage, or has the modern lifestyle simply caught up with the body's capacity to respond?

The relationship between weight and knee pain is obvious and undeniable. Being overweight stresses the weight-carrying joints such as knees, hips, and spine intensely. The Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health explains that almost 33% of all joint replacement operations have an obese patient.

When a person is standing or walking, the pressure on their knees is almost four times their body weight. For instance, a 150-pound person puts 600 pounds of pressure on their knees with every step. Climbing stairs, squatting, or running further intensifies this pressure, speeding up joint deterioration and elevating the risk of osteoarthritis.

For women, the issue is exacerbated by differences in anatomy. Women have a wider pelvis, which impacts the alignment of the tibia and femur, putting further stress on the knee joint. This, along with less muscle mass than men, predisposes them to issues like patellofemoral pain syndrome and osteoarthritis.

So, are women's knees evolutionarily handicapped to deal with excess weight, or did the obesity crisis just outgrow our body's ability to catch up? We talked to Dr. Ramkinkar Jha, Orthopaedic Surgery and Chief and Unit Head - Orthopaedics to get some answers and also how knee pain could affect you.

High Heels, Poor Footwear and Lifestyle Choices

Obesity is a large factor, yet lifestyle factors are also responsible for weaker knees among women. Research by the Society of Chiropodists and Podiatrists discovered that 25% of women regularly wear high heels. This footwear preference can change body posture and cause additional pressure to be put on the knees, causing damage to the joints with time.

In addition, the survey also pointed out that 77% of men and women do not use the right footwear for sports activities. Using the wrong shoes can cause joint strain and a higher risk of injury, speeding up the onset of musculoskeletal conditions.

Dr. Ramkinkar, stresses that bone strength is frequently compromised unbeknownst to people. Causes such as being inactive, too much caffeine, and inadequate diet lead to joint degeneration. Women are particularly under a dual burden due to hormonal changes affecting bone and cartilage health as well.

Is the 'Knee Gap' Real?

More often than not, I've wondered do women get equally as much medical treatment and attention for knee conditions as men do, or do orthopedics practice gender-based medicine as well? Well apparently so, even with severe knee pain, says experts, are women ignored for orthopedic treatments. The 'knee gap'—a term used to denote differences in medical treatment between women and men—implies that women might not always get the same level of attention for knee problems. Research has shown that women are less likely to be advised for knee replacement surgeries than men, even when they report the same pain levels and degree of symptoms. This is problematic in terms of gender bias in orthopedic treatment.

Furthermore, women's symptoms are often relegated to being age-related or milder, causing delays in treatment and diagnosis. To address this, there is a need for increased awareness, equal healthcare policies, and more individualized orthopedic care that takes into account gender-related anatomical and hormonal differences.

How Women Can Strengthen Their Knees and Prevent Joint Damage

With lifestyle and obesity contributing to speeding up knee issues, preventive actions can assist women in keeping their joints healthy and mobile. The following are some key strategies:

1. Emphasize Joint-Friendly Exercise

Swimming, cycling, and strength training are low-impact exercises that can improve knee stability and decrease stress. Regular exercise is crucial to maintain weight and avoid undue stress on the joints.

2. Emphasize Nutrition for Bone and Joint Health

A diet that is well-balanced, high in calcium, vitamin D, and protein is important to ensure strong cartilage and bones. Leafy vegetables, dairy foods, nuts, and fortified foods can be used to satisfy daily nutrient intake.

3. Wear the Correct Footwear

Steering clear of high heels and wearing properly cushioned, supportive shoes can ensure even distribution of weight and minimize pressure on the knees. Wearing exercise-specific shoes during exercise can also avoid injuries.

4. Live a Healthy Lifestyle

Elevation of excessive consumption of caffeine and alcohol, being well-hydrated, and performing weight-bearing activities will aid in sustaining long-term joint health. Optimal lifestyle helps avoid premature degradation of cartilage and maintains knee strength for decades to come.

Women's health are subjected to greater stress levels because of obesity, anatomical variations, and lifestyle. Even though biology also plays a factor, contemporary-day lifestyles and differences in healthcare only add to the issue.

Dr. Ramkinkar Jha is an Orthopaedic Surgery and Chief and Unit Head - Orthopaedics (Unit III) at Artemis Hospitals in India

End of Article

BMI Calculators Cannot Predict Your Risk Of Death - Which Metric Can We Use?

Updated Jul 16, 2025 | 07:00 PM IST

SummaryHealth is not a one way street, what may look healthy to certain people, may be opposite for others. While BMI has been used to define whether a person may be healthy, studies have found it to be inaccurate.
BMI Calculators Cannot Predict Your Risk Of Death - Which Metric Can We Use?

(Credit-Canva)

Health is not linear for everyone. Many people have skewed perception about health; they think a person who is thin is naturally healthy, while a person who is overweight is inherently unhealthy.

A recent study published in the Annals of Family Medicine suggests that BMI, a measure of body fat based on height and weight, is a poor predictor of a person's risk of death. Instead, the study highlights body fat percentage (BF%) as a more effective and easily assessed measurement during routine checkups.

Shortcomings of BMI

Doctors have traditionally used BMI to check a person's fat, bone, and muscle health, especially since body composition is linked to a higher risk of conditions like type 2 diabetes and heart disease. BMI is calculated by dividing a person's weight by their height squared.

While a higher BMI can sometimes suggest a greater chance of developing certain health problems, there's growing evidence that it's an imperfect measure. It doesn't consider important factors like a person's age, biological sex, or how their fat and muscle are distributed.

For example, top athletes often have a lot of muscle, which can give them a high BMI. Even though these athletes are very healthy, focusing only on their BMI might incorrectly label them as having obesity.

On the other hand, some people with a "normal" BMI might still be at a higher risk for conditions like diabetes, high blood pressure, and fatty liver disease. These individuals are sometimes referred to as having "normal weight obesity" or, in simpler terms, being "skinny fat."

Why Body Fat Percentage Might Be Superior

With the limitations of BMI in mind, researchers looked into how strongly BMI is connected to the risk of death. They also wanted to see if body fat percentage, which they described as "an easy, reliable, and inexpensive measure," could do a better job of predicting this risk.

The research team analyzed health information from thousands of adults. This data included height, weight, waist size, and body fat percentage. They calculated BMI for these individuals and then tracked who passed away over many years. After considering various factors, the scientists made some key discoveries:

There was no significant link between having a BMI categorized as obese (meaning a BMI of 25 or higher) and a greater risk of dying from any cause when compared to those with a "healthy" BMI.

Body fat percentage, however, provided clear insights into mortality risk. Individuals with a high body fat percentage (27% or more for men and 44% or more for women) were significantly more likely to die from any cause.

Waist size was less accurate than body fat percentage but still showed some connection to a higher risk of death.

The Future of Health Assessments

The study suggests that directly measuring body fat percentage, which is relatively inexpensive and easy to do in a doctor's office, is better at predicting future mortality risk than using BMI.

This doesn't mean doctors should stop using BMI entirely. It can still be a simple starting point to help determine if a patient needs to lose weight or gain muscle to prevent chronic diseases. But it should be seen as just that—"an easy first step."

Ideally, other measurements should also be taken. The more information doctors have—including BMI, waist size, body fat, blood pressure, and cholesterol—the more complete a picture they'll have of a patient's health. Modern devices can measure body fat percentage quickly, often in under a minute. It's hoped that more doctors will start using body fat percentage measurements, as a direct measure of body fat can be a valuable tool for preventing disease.

End of Article

Physician Associates Or Assistant Doctors? Government Review Urges Renaming To Avoid Misunderstandings

Updated Jul 16, 2025 | 04:18 PM IST

SummaryAfter multiple reports of people confusing the role of a physician associate and a doctor, the Leng review looked into the issue and what could be some solutions to it.
Physician Associates Or Assistant Doctors?

(Credit-Canva)

A recent independent review suggests that staff who help doctors in hospitals and GP offices, who are called Physician Associates (PAs) and Anaesthesia Associates (AAs), should be renamed "assistants." The review that has been in work since the past year has finally presented its findings and results. The Leng review has been looking into the various aspects of AAs and PAs to understand where there are shortcomings and why must there be changes.

One of the biggest issues that people have with PAs and AAs is confusing them with doctors. The review also recommends that these assistants wear specific uniforms and badges to clearly tell them apart from doctors. Crucially, it states that these assistants should not be the ones to diagnose patients' illnesses.

The UK Department of Health & Social Care called for this review last year due to ongoing debates about the exact roles and duties of these healthcare professionals. When PAs and AAs were first brought into the NHS in the early 2000s, there wasn't a clear plan for how they would fit into existing medical teams. This led to a lot of confusion about what they were supposed to do. Sometimes, when there weren't enough doctors, PAs filled in, even without the extensive training doctors receive, and without proper guidance from supervisors.

The report gives a full picture of the role of Medical Associate Professionals (MAPs) in UK healthcare.

Tragic Cases Highlight Confusion

The review heard from families who lost loved ones after they were treated by PAs, mistakenly believing they were qualified doctors. For example, a young woman died from a blood clot after being seen twice by a Physician Associate who thought her calf pain was just a sprain.

Another family shared how their elderly mother died from an infection after a PA treated her in hospital. While these families do not blame the assistants, they stress the need for much clearer identification and roles. They believe that in stressful hospital situations, patients and families might not fully grasp who is treating them.

Scrutiny And Problems Faced By MAPs

However, the College of Medical Associate Professionals also present the value of MAPs and how the public views them needs to get better. News and social media have sometimes created misunderstandings about what MAPs do and how they fit into healthcare teams. Patients sometimes get confused, thinking a PA is a doctor, even when efforts are made to explain the role. There's a need for clear public education campaigns to help people understand and accept MAPs in the NHS.

The report also highlights that MAPs are facing significant stress and negative feelings because of the current environment, which many call an "anti-MAP campaign." This negativity affects their mental health both at work and at home. They point to media stories, social media attacks, and strict new rules as major causes of distress.

Worryingly, bullying and harassment at work are common. Over a third of qualified MAPs reported being bullied, and many experienced online harassments. A large number of student MAPs also faced bullying during their training. These experiences have led many MAPs to consider leaving their jobs or actually leaving. Women MAPs and those from minority ethnic backgrounds were more affected, making up a larger share of those who left their jobs despite being a smaller group overall in the workforce.

The British Medical Association responds to the review highlighted that the report reveals how NHS England allowed these new roles to grow without properly checking if they were safe. They point to a lack of strong national leadership, no clear accountability, and a failure to listen to concerns raised by doctors, patients, and even coroners (who investigate deaths).

The BMA argues that allowing the roles of doctors and non-doctors to become unclear, even with the help of the General Medical Council (GMC), has been a serious problem. Many doctors, they say, will feel that their earlier warnings were justified.

Key Steps Taken to Improve Medical Assistant Roles

While the proposed name change is a positive step, many in the medical community believe more needs to be done to clearly define what these assistants can and cannot do to ensure safe teamwork in the NHS.

This report makes several important recommendations for Medical Associate Professionals (MAPs), like Physician Associates (PAs) and Anaesthesia Associates (AAs), to make their roles clearer and more effective.

Clearer Rules and More Power

The report strongly suggests creating official rules and standards for MAPs. This will help make sure they are held accountable and that the public trusts them more. Since new rules are already being put in place, this should bring more trust and stability to their roles.

It also recommends giving MAPs the ability to prescribe medicine and order certain X-rays. This change would allow them to do their jobs more efficiently and use their skills better. There should also be national standards for their training after they qualify and for how they can move up in their careers. This will ensure that MAPs across the country receive consistent training and development.

Better Teamwork and Support

The report advises putting more money into planning the healthcare workforce. This will allow for the smart growth of MAP roles, making sure there are enough of them to meet the needs of the NHS. MAPs can actually help improve the training of junior doctors, rather than hindering it.

Better teamwork and strong leadership will help MAPs fit in well, creating a unified healthcare team that benefits both medical staff and patients. The report also suggests doing regular checks using anonymous feedback from patients to keep track of how MAPs are performing and their overall impact.

Supporting MAPs' Well-being

Finally, the report highlights that the well-being of MAPs is a widespread issue within the healthcare system, not just about individual toughness. The rules set by medical groups must be made with the input of MAP leaders and checked carefully to ensure they don't unfairly exclude anyone. Feeling respected and safe at work is extremely important for keeping staff, ensuring patients are safe, and providing good care.

End of Article

NHS Warns People To Look Out For These Symptoms - If It Persists For More Than Two Days, Visit Your Doctor

Updated Jul 16, 2025 | 01:00 PM IST

SummaryContagious diseases can spread due to the negligence of just one person, going onto affecting hundreds in their vicinity. One such virus that the NHS has warned against is the norovirus. Here’s why
NHS Warns People To Look Out For These Symptoms - If It Persists For More Than Two Days, Visit Your Doctor

(Credit-Canva)

As summers progress in the UK, people are planning out vacations, and a restful summer evening as the long days give plenty of room to do things you wish to even after you finish your work. However, these plans can very well come to an end if you do not take the correct precautions.

The NHS has sent out an important alert because cases of norovirus, also known as the "winter vomiting bug," are higher than usual. Although norovirus, seasonally, is a bigger issue in winter, the rising number of cases prompted the NHS to warn people. In a social media post on platform X, they explained that this highly contagious illness is causing widespread concern, and the NHS is urging people to be aware of its symptoms. They've noted that while norovirus can spread all year round, current numbers are particularly elevated.

Norovirus: Symptoms and Self-Care

Norovirus typically causes diarrhea and vomiting. While these symptoms are very uncomfortable, they usually get better within a couple of days. The NHS advises that for most people, treating themselves at home is the best approach, emphasizing the importance of drinking plenty of fluids to avoid dehydration. Common symptoms of norovirus include:

  • Sudden nausea (feeling sick)
  • Vomiting
  • Diarrhea
  • Sometimes a fever, headaches, stomach cramps, and aching limbs

Recent Case Numbers

Recent data from the UK shows a significant increase in reported norovirus cases. Between May 26 and June 29 this year, there were over 16,600 cases, which is much higher than the average for the same period over the past five years.

However, the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) has also reported that norovirus cases are now starting to decline and are returning to expected levels after a seasonal peak. Even with this decline, the number of reports in recent weeks was still higher than the five-year average for that same time frame, mainly due to a high number of cases reported earlier in the period.

How Norovirus Spreads

Due to the contagious nature of the virus, one must remember to take correct precautions not to spread them. Even a small, seemingly insignificant move could cause you to become a carrier.

  • Don't wash your hands properly after using the toilet.
  • Are in close contact with someone who has the virus.
  • Touch surfaces or objects that have the virus and then touch your mouth.
  • Eat food prepared by someone with norovirus.
  • Consume contaminated water or food.

Preventing the Spread

To help stop norovirus from spreading, the NHS recommends some important steps. Always wash your hands thoroughly with soap and water after using the toilet, changing diapers, or before preparing or eating food. It's also important to remember that alcohol-based hand gels don't kill norovirus, so soap and water are essential.

If your clothes or bedding get soiled with vomit or feces, wash them at 60°C (140°F) and separately from other laundry. One must remember to regularly clean shared surfaces like toilet seats, flush handles, taps, and bathroom door handles. You must also try to avoid contact with others as much as possible if you feel unwell.

When to Stay Home and When to Seek Help

If you or your child start showing symptoms of norovirus, it's really important to stay home. Do not go to school, nursery, or work until you haven't thrown up or had diarrhea for two full days (48 hours). This helps prevent the virus from spreading further. Similarly, avoid visiting people in hospitals or care homes during this time. If you or your child have diarrhea that lasts for more than seven days, or if vomiting continues for more than two days, seek medical help.

End of Article